With numbers like these it’s no surprise that advertisers were willing to pay close to $3,000,000 for a thirty second spot, or $100,000 per second. In short, when it comes to the Super Bowl, no other media event provides anywhere close to the kind of “reach” that it does.
However, in today’s fast paced media environment where users are hit 100’s if not 1000’s of messages per day, is “reach” still the right metric to be looking at? Just because I’ve reached you, does that mean I have truly connected with you and made a lasting impression? Yes, advertising during the Super Bowl is the pinnacle of consumer branding, but when it comes to measuring the effectiveness of it as an advertising medium, I think its important that we start to look at other metrics in order to judge its impact.
Introducing a new metric – “Connectivity”
In today’s ever increasingly “social world” more and more brands are looking to leverage social media as a means to connect and form relationships with consumers. Therefore, I’d like to argue that if this is true, the effectiveness of advertising mediums and the ads that appear within them should be measured by not just by how effectively they reach the consumer, but more importantly how effectively they connect consumers with the brand.
And, what better way is there to measure this by than the 800lb Gorilla, known as Facebook. In short, one would think that if you were to advertise on a stage as big as the Super Bowl, not only would you reach users; you would connect with them as well. Yes, some Super Bowl XLV advertisers were more “social” than others, but when you are advertising on a medium a large as the Super Bowl, I’d like to think that it should have the residual effect of motivating those you “reach” to want to further “connect” and establish an ongoing relationship via social media, specifically Facebook.
Facebook “Like” Growth of Key Super Bowl Advertisers
In order to test my theory I decided to look at the Facebook fan base of 24 Super Bowl advertisers at 3pm on Sunday, February 6th, prior to the Big Game. I then revisited these same pages at 8pm (29 hours later) on Monday, February 7th, as I wanted to give people enough time to absorb the ads and have ample time to get off the couch and onto Facebook. The following are the results:
As you will see when it comes to connecting with consumers via Social Media, the Super Bowl had very little impact. In all, only 85,611 Likes were garnered across all of these major brands, which accounted for an increase of just 0.19%! While Coca Cola scored the largest volume increase of Likes at 19,942, this equated to overall growth of just 0.09%. Likewise Teleflora (Nice Rack) had the largest percentage increase of Likes at 4.76%, but this equated to total numerical growth of just 183 Likes.
In the end, while the Super Bowl does have reach, when it comes to connecting with users via Social Media, specifically via Facebook, and creating lasting relationships, it has a long way to go. Because of its audience and cultural impact, the Super Bowl will always get top dollar, but as time evolves and the landscape only becomes more cluttered, how we measure effectiveness is going to change. Social Media is only become more important and valuable to us as marketers and it’s my belief that being able to apply hard metrics about the ability of media and advertising to “connect” with consumers, not just reach them, is the success metric of the future.
Tags: Advertising, Advertising Spending, Facebook, Marketing, Social Media, Social Media Marketing
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by TyVelde and TyVelde, louisgudema. louisgudema said: RT @ovrdrv The Super Bowl Has Reach, But Does It Really Connect? http://is.gd/XOGiRh #marketing #in [...]
While I overall agree the Super Bowl has a long way to go I think your analysis here is a bit flawed. To really make this work you’d have to look at the increase of top brands that did not advertise Sunday, or the same brands a week before.
.2% may not seem like a lot, but for 24 hours, it just might be significant. Consider that you are trying to measure whether or not a television commercial can motivate someone to “like” a brand. That’s a pretty powerful commercial – and a lot to ask for any 30 sec spot.
Thanks for your feedback and appreciate you taking time to read my post.
My goal however was to look at the impact that advertising on a medium as large as the Super Bowl has on motivating users to like a brand in the immediate time when the ad was running and thereafter. While brands that did not advertise may of had similar and/or varied results, in my opinion that would just further highlight the limited impact that Super Bowl advertising has in terms of getting users to connect with a brand via social media, specifically facebook. Likewise, if I had looked at brands that did advertise a week prior, and found that the results from Sunday were higher than in previous weeks, while it would have resulted in percentage gains, the baseline numbers would still all be very small. Therefore, this analysis would still have shown the limited impact, in terms of pure volume, that Super Bowl advertising had on getting users to connect with the brands via FB.
As for the .2% increase, while not insignificant, my assumption was that it would have been larger given the size and scale of the audience and assocaited creative message being put forth. Again, this is being viewed within the context of the Super Bowl and the massive audience it affords, and in my opinion these are not your average :30 spots. When you’re paying upwards of $3,000,000 to access an audience of 100mm people, in my opinion, .2% is a very small lift and I assumed it would have resulted in more cross-pollination in terms of users looking to connect with the brand’s FB presence, which really did not happen for any of the advertisers.
I like connecting over reaching. But I find the assumption that a Facebook like is the de facto metric for connecting too limited.
The most obvious connections are turning to your pal and saying “Cool ad huh?” Or sharing it as YouTube clip on Monday at work. Or doing a google search. Indeed a cusory glance at Google Insights for Search (“the biggest database of intentions in the world”) shows clear search spikes for three of the brands on your list (VW, Groupon, Teleflora).
In short: Liking a brand on Facebook may not be the best place to see a consumer connection, despite what agencies, brands and facebook might like to think…
cerita dewasa panas…
[...]The Social Bowl – The Super Bowl Has Reach, But Does It Really Connect? | Overdrive eMarketing Blog: Social Media Marketing | Search Engine Marketing[...]…